The billing-to-collections gap is the difference between what a healthcare clinic is entitled to collect under its payer contracts and what it actually banks. Revenue disappears to denials, underpayments, write-offs, and uncollected patient balances. Stan Sukhinin's rule of thumb is 12 to 18% of expected collectible revenue for clinics that are not tracking those three things closely. Clinics that do track them tend to land much closer to the published medians: MGMA's physician-owned groups collect a median of 98.72% of expected collectible revenue, a gap of about 1.3%.
The denominator matters, and most articles on this get it wrong. The gap is not gross charges minus collections. Gross charges are set by your chargemaster and bear little relation to what any payer has agreed to pay; the difference between them is the contractual adjustment, and it is normal, expected, and not lost money. A practice that bills $500K in charges against contracts worth $300K and collects $290K has not lost 42%. It has lost 3.3% of what it was owed.
So the metric is:
Expected collectible revenue = gross charges − contractual adjustments The gap = (expected collectible − actual collections) ÷ expected collectible
That is the number worth chasing, because every dollar in it was contractually yours.
From $65K to $900K on a $5M practice
This post walks through the five places the gap tends to hide, and how to measure your own. If your billing team says everything is fine, start with billing-team-says-everything-is-fine.
Stan's rule of thumb is 12 to 18% of expected collectible revenue for a clinic that is not tracking denials, underpayments, and patient balances. On a $5M multi-location clinic, that estimate works out to $600K to $900K a year.
Compare that with the MGMA median: physician-owned groups collect 98.72% of expected collectible revenue, a gap of about 1.3%, or $65K on the same $5M. That is the spread between a clinic that tracks this closely and one that does not.
None of it is lost to bad debt or low patient volume. It is lost in the space between billing a claim and collecting the cash: timing gaps, process failures, and numbers that nobody reconciles.
Run the same 12 to 18% estimate on a single-location practice doing $1.5M and you get $180K to $270K a year. Run the MGMA median on the same practice and you get about $20K. Where your clinic actually falls between those two numbers is the question worth answering.
Where does all that money go?
The five places to look
Here are the five places to look, and how to check each one in your own numbers.
1. Slow claim submission
The clock starts ticking the moment a patient walks out of your office. Every day between the date of service and the date the claim is submitted is a day your cash is delayed. But delay is not the only problem.
Some claims never get submitted at all. They get stuck in a coding queue. The provider did not finish the note. The front desk entered the insurance wrong. The claim needs a modifier that nobody added. It sits in a "hold" bucket in the billing system.
Pull your own number: the average days between date of service and claim submission, for the last quarter. MGMA puts the sector norm at three to seven days of charge-posting lag; if yours runs longer, that is cash sitting still, not cash lost, unless claims age past the payer's timely-filing deadline. At high-volume practices, even a few extra days of lag means tens of thousands of dollars sitting outside the payment pipeline at any given time.
2. Incorrect contractual adjustments
When a payer sends a payment, the difference between your billed charge and the allowed amount gets written off as a contractual adjustment. This is normal. Your fee schedule says $200, the contract says the payer pays $140, you write off $60.
The problem is when the adjustment is wrong. The payer sends $120 instead of $140, and the adjustment is automatically posted as $80. Nobody checks whether that $120 matched the contracted rate. The billing system accepts the payment, posts the adjustment, and moves on.
Across hundreds of claims per month, incorrect adjustments add up fast. Pull twenty or thirty payments from the last month and check the posted adjustment against your actual fee schedule, not against what the billing system assumed. It is the only way to know your own number. Across multiple locations, errors compound, so run the sample per location to see where to focus first.
3. Denied claims that die in a pile
I wrote about this in detail in my previous post on denied claims. The "roughly 65%" figure you see cited everywhere turns out to be a Medicaid number. An NBER study of physician claims found that 65.8% of denied Medicaid claims are never resubmitted, against about 38% for Medicare and 40% for commercial insurance.
Here is the arithmetic for a commercial-heavy practice. Take a $5M clinic with an 8% denial rate, the top of MGMA's four-year benchmark for first-submission denials, and for example a payer mix of 70% commercial, 20% Medicare, and 10% Medicaid. That is $400K in denied claims. Weighting the non-resubmission rates above by that mix works out to about 42%, so roughly $170K sits abandoned every year. A practice with more Medicaid in the mix, or a higher denial rate, loses more. A practice that works every denial loses close to nothing here.
The denial itself is not always the problem. The problem is the absence of a process to work denials systematically. Claims get denied, they sit in a queue, they age past timely filing limits, and the revenue is gone.
4. Underpayments nobody catches
This is different from incorrect contractual adjustments. Underpayments happen when a payer simply pays less than the contracted rate, and nobody notices.
Your contract with a payer says they will pay $185 for a specific CPT code. They send $160. The payment gets posted. The balance gets adjusted. Nobody compares the payment to the fee schedule. That silent underpayment is exactly what first-pass resolution rate tracking catches.
To catch underpayments, you need two things: access to your payer contracts with the actual fee schedules, and a process for comparing payments against those schedules. Most clinics have the contracts filed away somewhere but have never built the comparison into their billing workflow.
Run that comparison on a month of payments from your top five payers before you guess at the size of the problem. The answer can surprise you in either direction.
5. Missed charges
Services rendered but never billed. This is the leak that surprises clinic owners the most because it happens before the billing process even starts.
A provider does a procedure but does not document it in the note. A front desk staff member checks in the patient but does not capture the correct service. A lab is performed but the order is not linked to a billable encounter.
Missed charges are the hardest leak to quantify because there is no record of what was never billed. The way to find them is to compare provider schedules and patient encounter data against claims submitted. Any encounter with no matching claim is worth investigating.
Run that comparison for a single week before you estimate the size of the problem. For example, a 2% miss rate at a practice seeing 200 patients a day across three locations is 4 encounters a day, and at a $150 average encounter value, that is $600 a day, or close to $156K a year if it runs uncorrected. Whether your actual miss rate is near zero or closer to that is something you can only know by running the comparison.
Why most clinic owners never see it
The problem is structural. Your practice operates with two separate financial views, and nobody puts them together.
View 1: The billing company. They see claims, payments, denials, and adjustments. They report a collection rate based on their data. That rate typically looks good because of how it is calculated. Many billing companies report an adjusted collection rate: payments divided by charges minus contractual adjustments. That is the right formula, but it flatters you when denials and small balances get written off as contractual adjustments, because those dollars drop out of the denominator. By that math, you can have serious revenue leaks and still show a 95% collection rate.
View 2: The accountant. They see bank deposits, expenses, and profit. They reconcile your books against your bank statements. They have no visibility into what was billed, what was denied, what was underpaid, or what was never billed in the first place. This is the gap that your accountant seeing only bank deposits creates — and why billing data and accounting data need to be reconciled together.
Neither view is wrong. But neither view is complete. The gap between them is where revenue disappears.
How to measure it
The measurement is straightforward.
Step 1. Pull total charges and total contractual adjustments from your billing system for a given month. Charges minus adjustments is your expected collectible revenue — what your contracts actually entitle you to. Do not skip the adjustments; measuring against gross charges produces a frightening number that means nothing.
Step 2. Pull total collections (payments received) from your billing system for the same period. Remember that collections for a given month include payments on claims from previous months, so compare on a claim cohort basis if you can, not a calendar one.
Step 3. Pull total bank deposits for that month. Separate out non-patient-revenue deposits (loans, grants, owner contributions).
Step 4. Compare billing collections to bank deposits. They should match closely. If billing says you collected $400K but your bank shows $370K in patient-revenue deposits, you have a $30K gap to investigate.
Step 5. Break it down by payer. Which payers have the largest gap between expected and actual payments? Break it down by location. Which locations have the worst collection performance?
This is what a location-level P&L with billing data integration looks like. It is the most useful financial report a multi-location clinic can have.
What good looks like
There is no published collection benchmark by outpatient specialty that we can point you to. These are the yardsticks that are published:
| Source | What it measures | Figure |
|---|---|---|
| MGMA, physician-owned groups | Median adjusted fee-for-service collection rate | 98.72% |
| MGMA, hospital-owned groups | Median adjusted fee-for-service collection rate | 97.81% |
| HFMA | Net collection rate | 95% minimum, 97 to 99% optimal |
| AAFP | Adjusted collection rate | 95% minimum |
MGMA's adjusted rate and HFMA's net rate are the same measure under two names: payments divided by charges minus contractual adjustments. Ask your billing company which denominator it uses before you compare. Below 95%, money is leaking somewhere in the five places above. Between 95% and the 98.7% median, it is worth finding out which payer or location is pulling you down.
Where we start
If the gap is what pushes you toward hiring an RCM company, run the numbers first. We laid out the break-even math in outsourcing revenue cycle management, including why the fee matters far less than what your billing already costs you.
If you have never reconciled your billing data with your bank deposits across all your locations, that is where we start. The PT clinic whose collections looked normal until someone reconciled them is what that first step looked like in practice, and it is standard in our healthcare accounting engagements.
We do exactly this for our clients. We pull billing data, bank statements, and payer contracts. We map where money falls out at every stage, from one set of numbers rather than the billing company's version and the accountant's.
Take the free assessment to find out where your practice stands.



