How do you prepare a medical practice for a Medicare RAC audit?
Preparing for a Medicare Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) audit comes down to documentation discipline, internal coding audits, and a defined response workflow. The RAC reviews paid claims to identify improper payments, and you have 45 days to respond to medical record requests. Practices that audit their own coding quarterly, retain documentation per CMS rules, and assign a clear point person handle RAC inquiries as routine; practices that do none of those things treat each request as a crisis.
Want this answered for your own clinic?
Definition
A Medicare Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) audit is a post-payment review of Medicare claims by a CMS-contracted auditor authorized to identify and recover improper payments to providers; RACs are paid on a contingency basis from the amounts they recover.
The detail
RACs review paid Medicare fee-for-service claims for overpayments and underpayments, focused on issues CMS has approved on its RAC issue list. Common targets in outpatient practice are evaluation and management (E/M) level upcoding, modifier 25 usage, medical necessity for high-cost procedures and imaging, duplicate billing, and incorrect place-of-service coding. Preparation has four layers. Layer one is documentation hygiene. CMS's fact sheet on 42 CFR 424.516(f) tells providers and suppliers that furnish or order Medicare services to keep medical records for 7 years from the date of service; state law can require longer. Templates that auto-populate documentation without provider review are a common audit failure point. Each note must independently support medical necessity, the level of service billed, and any modifiers applied. Layer two is internal coding audit. Run a quarterly internal audit on a sample of high-risk codes for your specialty: 99214/99215 mix, modifier 25 claims, imaging studies, infusions, procedures with shared E/M services. Have a certified coder (CPC or specialty equivalent) review documentation against the billed code and flag any that would not survive external review. Track the error rate and remediate. Layer three is response workflow. Designate a RAC point person, usually your billing manager or compliance officer. When a record request arrives, log it, calendar the 45-day response window, pull the requested records, and have the supporting provider sign off on the response. Send by tracked, traceable method and retain the audit trail. If you miss the window, the contractor has authority to deny the claim; CMS says late documentation is accepted only for good cause. Layer four is appeal readiness. RAC findings can be appealed through five levels: redetermination, reconsideration, ALJ hearing, Medicare Appeals Council, and federal court. The first two levels are decided by Medicare contractors; the third is a decision by the Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals. Practices that win on appeal typically do so because their documentation, not their argument, was strong. If you discover systemic upcoding or miscoding during prep, talk to a healthcare attorney about a voluntary self-disclosure to OIG; that is a separate decision with significant legal implications and should not be made unilaterally.
For post-payment reviews by MACs, SMRC and RACs, providers get 45 calendar days to respond to an additional documentation request; if they do not respond in time, the contractor has authority to deny the claim.
RACs review only topics CMS has approved and posts on its RAC review topics page, which lists the codes, provider types, regions and policy references for each review.
Source: CMS Recovery Audit Program
There are five levels in the Medicare Part A and Part B appeals process: redetermination by a MAC, reconsideration by a QIC, a decision by the Office of Medicare Hearings and Appeals, review by the Medicare Appeals Council, and judicial review in federal district court.
What this means for clinic owners
From Sorso
A RAC audit is not a catastrophe if your documentation is honest and your coding is defensible. The work is upstream: clean templates, quarterly internal coding audits, a designated point person, and a defined 45-day workflow. Practices that build that discipline treat audit requests as a routine cost of operating in Medicare. Practices that hope to avoid scrutiny by staying small or quiet eventually pay for that hope with refunds, penalties, and provider time spent in appeals.
Talk it through
Want Stan to look at this for your clinic?
Stan Sukhinin, CFA, founded Sorso in 2020: a fractional CFO and accounting firm for outpatient clinics across the US, with accounting from $1,500 a month and fractional CFO from $4,000. Book a free 30-minute call, bring the question and, if you have it, last month's P&L, and he will tell you what he would check first.
Continue with Sorso
How clinic owners typically work with us after a question like this
Fractional CFO
Strategic CFO for $3M–$50M clinics
Forecasts, location-level P&L, exit prep. Starts at $4,000/mo.
Explore Fractional CFO →Accounting
Healthcare-specialist accounting
Books done right by people who understand clinic finance. Starts at $1,500/mo.
Explore Accounting →Free Assessment
See where your clinic stands
4-minute, 15-question diagnostic. Personalized scorecard emailed to you.
Take the Free Assessment →Related questions
What records do I need to keep for an IRS audit?
Keep tax records for at least 3 years after filing (the general period of limitations), 6 years if you left out income of more than 25 percent of the gross income on the return, 4 years for employment tax records, and asset records until the limitations period ends for the year you dispose of the asset. Fraudulent or unfiled returns have no limit, HIPAA documentation must be kept 6 years, and medical record retention is set by state law.
What is modifier 25 used for?
Modifier 25 indicates that a significant, separately identifiable Evaluation and Management (E/M) service was performed by the same physician on the same day as a procedure, allowing both to be billed when properly documented.
What are the most common billing errors in healthcare?
The most common healthcare billing errors are eligibility verification failures, missing prior authorization, incorrect or missing modifiers (especially modifier 25 and 59), upcoding/downcoding, missing documentation for medical necessity, and timely filing failures.
Founder of Sorso and a CFA charterholder. Before Sorso, Stan spent 19 years in corporate finance at institutions including UniCredit and Société Générale — managing a $450M loan portfolio and making senior partner at a major mezzanine lender by 29 — then built a fractional CFO firm exclusively for outpatient healthcare clinics.
Want to see how your practice measures up?
Take the 4-minute financial assessment. It is free, and it will show you where your practice is leaking money.